The Best Home Warranty Companies of 2024

Let our home warranty experts do the research for you!

Liberty Homeguard Logo

Verified Partner

  • Claims-first warranty company
  • Wide selection of optional coverages
  • Highly ranked by customers
  • Online quotes for all policies
  • Two months free with annual payment
  • Does not require a home inspection
  • Flexible plan lengths
  • 60-day workmanship guarantee on repairs
  • 24/7 customer service
Best Overall
  • Claims-first warranty company
  • Wide selection of optional coverages
  • Highly ranked by customers & BBB
  • Online quotes for all policies
  • Two months free with annual payment
  • Flexible plan lengths
  • 60-day workmanship guarantee on repairs
  • 24/7 customer service
Best Overall

Call Now
(833) 543-9600

  • Flexible service fees
  • No coverage cap for systems
  • Can use own contractor in some cases
  • Does not require a home inspection
  • Good online customer reviews
  • Limited number of add-on services offered
  • Not available in Alaska, Hawaii, or New York City
  • Plans from top-rated providers in one place
  • Free online quotes in under a minute
  • No-exam coverage available
  • 30-day free look period
  • Product variety
  • Great customer service - live agents
choice home warranty logo

Verified Partner

  • Coverage available in most states
  • Affordable covergae plans
  • High coverage limits
  • 24/7 call centers
  • Nationwide Network of more than 25,000 Contractors
  • First month free
  • Only two plan options
  • Coverage available in most states
  • Affordable covergae plans
  • High coverage limits
  • 24/7 call centers
  • Nationwide Network of more than 25,000 Contractors
  • First month free
  • Only two plan options
  • Multiple plan choices
  • Different contract length options
  • Choose your own technician
  • Workmanship guarantee for entire plan term
  • More expensive than many competitors
  • Not available in California, Hawaii, and Washington
  • Multiple plan choices
  • Different contract length options
  • Choose your own technician
  • Workmanship guarantee for entire plan term
  • More expensive than many competitors
  • Not available in California, Hawaii, and Washington
  • Comprehensive coverages in top plans
  • Affordable service fee
  • Up to $7,000 coverage limit per term per appliance
  • Only available in 37 states
  • Can’t choose own contractor
  • Comprehensive coverages in top plans
  • Affordable service fee
  • Up to $7,000 coverage limit per term per appliance
  • Only available in 37 states
  • Can’t choose own contractor
  • Claims assistance is available 24/7
  • Offers customizable plans
  • Real estate pro plans available
  • Excludes clothes washer and dryer coverage from its entry-level plans
  • Not available in all states
  • Choosing own contractor discouraged
  • Claims assistance is available 24/7
  • Offers customizable plans
  • Real estate pro plans available
  • Excludes clothes washer and dryer coverage from its entry-level plans
  • Not available in all states
  • Choosing own contractor discouraged

Finding the Best Home Warranty Company

Choosing the right home warranty company, however, can be a challenge. New companies keep coming up every year, just as often as old ones die away. Also, warranty companies can be over the top with advertising. So, separating the good from bad isn’t easy.

Luckily, we’ve been in the industry long enough to know what to look for in a great provider. Here’s how we choose the best warranty companies:

 Thorough Coverage

There are three broad categories of warranties:

  • those that cover the structure only
  • those that cover appliances only
  • and those that cover both the structure and appliances.

We prefer providers that cover both the structure and appliances. Even though these types of warranties can be expensive, they give you greater peace of mind.

Another thing we consider is what types of appliances and how many appliances in total the warranty covers in the basic plan. The greater the variety and higher the number of appliances covered, the more value you get for your money.

 Generous Caps

Speaking of money, you also want to choose a provider that pays generously for arising issues. Whether it’s a problem with the building itself or an appliance, the company should be willing to cover a significant portion, if not the entire cost.

This applies especially to replacements although repairs should also be kept in mind. Some home warranty providers are not willing to cover expensive replacements, often leaving homeowners with a heavy burden on their shoulders.

To determine the best warranty providers, we begin by finding out what each company pays for common situations and comparing the figures with caps from other companies. The best companies are those that are ready to back the consumer with generous caps or by removing maximum caps altogether.

 Reliable Support

Another issue is customer support. Every single day consumers file complaints about service providers who won’t pick their calls. And, home warranty companies have been mentioned quite a bit. Something that’s covered in the warranty agreement breaks down and you call your company all day in vain.

We’re aware of this and always exclude notorious companies from out lists. If a company has been frequently mentioned for failing to pick calls or respond to clients’ messages, we wouldn’t recommend such a company.

We also try to leave out companies that put policyholders on hold for too long as well as those whose sales reps want to jump into a sales pitch without even listening to the client.

 Quick Turnaround

When you have a problem with the house or perhaps an appliance, a warranty agreement says that you should call the company right away. The problem is that sometimes you may do exactly that and still be forced to wait days before a technician comes in to take a look at the situation.

It’s important to find a warranty provider that won’t put you through such headaches. What if it’s a washing machine that has refused to work – on laundry day? Do you sit there a whole day waiting for the technician? Or it could be an issue with the plumbing that requires urgent action.

You can’t wait for long with such issues. Therefore, we also consider turnaround time and favor companies that do their best to respond within the shortest time.

 Clear Terms

Finally, a home warranty provider should be very clear about what is covered, what is not, and the course of action in every possible eventuality. Some companies have a habit of concealing important details of a contract by using confusing language. We only consider companies that lay everything open and use simple, easy to understand words.

Also, we’re aware of companies that try not to say the amount they’ll pay in the event of a situation. These companies are also excluded from our best home warranty provider lists. Instead, we only recommend providers that have stated clearly how much they pay for specific situations and how much the policyholder is required to pay.

If you’re currently looking to purchase a home warranty, we recommend that you pick from the list above. If you choose not to, keep our above-mentioned criteria in mind. You’ll find a great provider.

How to Pick the Right Provider

Choosing the right home warranty company requires thoughtful consideration to ensure your home and its systems are adequately protected. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you pick the most suitable provider:

  1. Assess Your Needs: Begin by evaluating your home’s systems and appliances to determine which ones you want to cover under the warranty. Consider factors such as the age, condition, and frequency of repairs for each item.

  2. Research Providers: Explore different home warranty companies in your area and online. Look for reputable companies with a track record of reliability, excellent customer service, and positive reviews from homeowners.

  3. Compare Coverage Plans: Review the coverage options offered by each provider. Compare the items covered, exclusions, service call fees, and coverage limits to ensure they align with your needs and budget.

  4. Examine Contract Terms: Carefully read the terms and conditions of each home warranty contract. Pay attention to coverage limitations, exclusions, waiting periods, and renewal terms. Ensure you understand all the terms before signing up.

  5. Check Service Network: Verify that the home warranty company has a network of qualified service technicians in your area. A broad service network ensures timely and efficient repairs when needed.

  6. Consider Customer Support: Evaluate the responsiveness and quality of customer support provided by each company. Look for companies with 24/7 customer service and easy-to-reach representatives to assist you with claims and inquiries.

  7. Review Pricing and Fees: Compare pricing structures and fees for each home warranty plan. Consider factors such as monthly premiums, service call fees, and any additional costs associated with coverage. Choose a plan that offers good value for the coverage provided.

  8. Look for Additional Benefits: Some home warranty companies offer additional benefits such as discounts on appliance purchases, free maintenance services, or coverage for items like pool equipment or roof repairs. Consider these extras when making your decision.

  9. Check Financial Stability: Verify the financial stability of the home warranty company by checking their ratings with independent agencies such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or A.M. Best. A financially stable company is more likely to fulfill their obligations and pay out claims promptly.

  10. Seek Recommendations: Ask friends, family, or real estate professionals for recommendations based on their experiences with home warranty companies. Personal referrals can provide valuable insights into the reliability and service quality of different providers.

By following these steps and conducting thorough research, you can confidently select a home warranty company that offers the right coverage and support to protect your home and provide peace of mind for you and your family.

How We Rank Top Companies

To help you find the perfect home warranty policy, we rank the top companies on the market and round up the policies that offer the best possible coverage. Once you have identified your needs and the needs of your family, you have to choose the policy that will satisfy all your requirements. We do this by evaluating companies based on their customer reviews, financial strength ratings, and customer complaint frequency. All of these factors determine how well a warranty company will be able to serve you should you need to make a claim. 

Customer service and experience are essential parts of ranking warranty companies and their policies. Things like the usability of a company’s website, the ease with which you can get a quote, and the availability of the customer service team are all important considerations. Knowing how satisfied you can expect to be when you work with a warranty company will help you find the perfect provider for your needs.

2024 © Consumer Review Center, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The contents of this site may not be republished, reprinted, rewritten or recirculated without written permission.